You know, I am not an emotional guy. I can even be a bit of an asshole at times. But I’m frustrated almost to the point of tears not only over what is happening (and not happening) to the people of New Orleans, but over what US the media are saying about it.
Flipping back and forth between American news sources like CNN and Fox and international ones like the BBC reminds me of watching the news in China. Yes, it’s almost that bad at times. The US news tells a tale of unexpected disaster that could not have been prevented and and uncaring world, and the foreign press tells a story of gross bureaucratic incompetence and a nation refusing all outside help.
A few random facts about international aid.
A few days ago the Dutch (who know a thing or two about repairing levees) sent a ship full of food, medicine and rescue and repair specialists to the Gulf. A politician (the president?) was on TV saying that while America had not actually accepted their offer of aid yet, they wanted to be in position in case the US finally accepts. (Thank you!) Even Cuba offered to send doctors and/or water and supplies, but they are not being allowed to. At last count, over 70 nations have offered hundreds of millions of dollars in aid, but very little of this aid is being accepted by the the federal government.
And it’s not just the international aid that’s being turned away. The mayor of Chicago offered to send rescue personal and was refused. The Red Cross has tucks full of supplies that FEMA will not let them deliver. The Mayor of New Orleans was on (foreign) TV the other night, saying that things are getting worse and that what the federal government and US media are saying is a “line of bull.” I can’t help but wonder how much widespread notice his statements received in the US.
The Independent (an English newspaper) ran an analysis of what went wrong, and they came to the conclusion that the disaster probably could have been avoided. I will not get into the details here, but the two main points were organization and funding. FEMA used to be an independent agency tasked with providing emergency relief, but after 911, Bush placed it under the authority of Homeland Security, changed its mission and reduced its funding.
The second problem was overall funding. Over the last four years federal funding for flood prevention and levee repair in New Orleans was cut almost in half. And last year — for the first time in 37 years — work on strengthening levees was halted due to lack of funds.
Katrina was a tragedy, but far more lives have been lost and continue to be lost due to criminal levels of incompetence than due to the storm itself. Its hard to explain how infuriating it is to switch between US and non-US news sources and see what a different story each is telling.
Most of this terrible loss of life is due to human incompetence and could have been prevented, but I don’t think anyone will ever be held accountable.